Saturday, May 12, 2007

Recollections of the Battle of Soui Tre, Vietnam on March 21, 1967

"One of the war's greatest victories." VFW Magazine.

I had been the Recon platoon leader in the 2nd Battalion, 22d Infantry (Mechanized), a.k.a. "Triple Deuce"(radio call sign: “Fullback”), for a couple of months prior to March 21st, 1967. The following recollections are sketchy in part but also with specific, very vivid memories interspersed. The battalion was operating as part of Operation Junction City and Fire Support Base Gold was established at a hot LZ near Soui Tre (a dot on the map only). The full 3d Battalion, 22d Infantry secured the perimeter at Gold for the 2d Battalion of the 77th Artillery (DS). Prior to March 21st our battalion had been involved in S&D (Search & Destroy) operations in assigned areas mainly to the west of Soui Tre.

On the night of the 20th of March, my battalion commander, LTC Ralph Julian, assigned Charlie company, commanded by Cpt George C. White, an area of operations with alert notice of possible need to reinforce FSB Gold. My Recon platoon was attached to Charlie company for more fire power. Charlie company had been and continued, through at least January 1968 when it fought decisively at FSB Burt (Soui Cut - another dot on the map)[1], to be the most aggressive and competent of the line companies.[2] I was not happy with the attachment of my platoon to a line company, even Charlie company. Recon had operated continuously and successfully as a separate maneuver unit. The men in the platoon firmly told me of their dissatisfaction with the attachment that night as well. Insult seemed to be heaped onto insult when White directed me to bring the Recon platoon up the rear of his company. My platoon had been having sustained VC contact prior to the 20th of March and possibly White wanted to give us a break. Whatever the reason, it did not sit very well with me though I did not say anything to White whom I greatly respected. Recon had always been out front and in the thick of it and as it turned out on March 21st the “insults” would put us right back at the front and in the heat of battle.

Charlie moved out and we pulled in behind. We had not moved for very long when George White called me[3] and advised that he had been ordered to immediately move to reinforce the units at FSB Gold. He directed us to turn the individual tracks in-place and Recon was to be the lead unit in Fullback’s reinforcement effort. I have to say that there was, in fact, a small smile on my face and shouts on the platoon radio of “Yes!” and “Let’s get em!”. When it came to moving the M113 tracks, Recon drivers were outstanding and we spun and began to move. Soon after we had all turned 180 degrees and I had moved to the new front of the column as the third track we started off. Looking off to my left I saw an RPG round in the air heading toward us but striking a large termite hill about 30 yards from our line. I doubt that any one else saw it due to our positions. There was no other VC contact so I chose not to engage the enemy there given the immediacy of our need to get to FSB Gold. At the time I considered it a deliberate effort to engage and stall all or some of us. As we moved through the thick jungle, the drivers ( I wish that I could recall the lead driver’s name!) did a superb job. Other units including elements of the 2d Battalion of the 34th Armor and the 2d Battalion of the 12th Infantry (leg infantry) were also moving toward Gold to reinforce. Given the speed of our movement literally “over” the trees and jungle and our unfamiliarity of the situation at Gold my platoon was detached from Charlie and I again had direct radio contact with our battalion CO, LTC Ralph Julian. Julian was in a bubble top helicopter at tree top level drawing fire and directing our column through the jungle into Soui Tre. Along the way we encountered tanks of the 2d/34th Armor that had been moving to the battle but had thrown tracks and couldn’t effectively move through the jungle. Recon followed by Charlie passed them by but they joined in behind us through the paths we had cleared. Our tracks broke enough jungle for the tanks to join further back in the column. I recall crossing no major water obstacle but then again my focus was on getting to Soui Tre in a hurry.[4] As we moved I began to get and passed on updates on the battle at FSB Gold that finally included reports of several breaches of the perimeter and hand to hand fighting within. The Artillery had lowered their guns to fire directly into the enemy waves. One round had to be fired to destroy one of their own "quad 50's" that the VC had overrun and were attempting to turn against the Americans. My drivers broke through thick jungle and overcame obstacles with ever increasing determination as they heard the reports. During the movement, due to the superb skills of the drivers and the sergeants directing them we did not throw a single track on any of the M113's - a relatively easy mishap in M113 maneuvers through the jungle

Eventually we broke through into a large open area at Soui Tre and I could see the smoke ahead from the battle centered to our northeast about 600 meters to our front. At this point I asked LTC Julian for guidance as to how to deploy most effectively . He said that he was not certain of the immediate need and that I should contact the commanders on the ground at the firebase. As our tracks broke into the clearing and moved toward the firebase and after I had spoken to Julian I recall seeing bodies on the ground in front of our tracks. Impulsively I had the thought to call the platoon and warn them to be careful and not run anyone over (too many days as a safety officer in the States I guess). Almost as instantaneously, and fortunately before I gave the command, it hit me that the prone figures in the open grass were the enemy and they were shooting at us. My perception was that the events began to move more slowly but in reality things were happening very quickly from that point on.

Our movement to the FSB once we had broken out into the clearing was direct and in a single column, Recon, Charlie Co., 2/34 Armor. I brought the lead track right to the edge of the 3d/22nd perimeter and they angled out facing the attack. The defensive position was smoldering. It gave an appearance of having been flattened and what had been, I am sure, a circular defensive position was clearly broken at several points. I was in the third track and as my track came to the edge of the defensive perimeter I could see and immediately recognized two LTC’s moving toward me on the ground in front of me with smiles from ear to ear.[5] I had jumped up to the top of the track in case I had needed to get on the ground to coordinate. Their smiles and proximity kept me on top of the track, a location that, in retrospect, was, at the least, ill-advised. There were an awful lot of bullets whizzing past. I yelled down “Which way should we go?” “”Anyway you want!” came the replies through the smiles. At this point I got on the radio and looked back behind me. Stretching all the way back into the jungle break out point was an awesome single file of M113's and tanks. The sound of the engines almost seemed to overcome the battle sounds. It must have been a truly frightening site and sound to the enemy. At that point I wish that I had thought to say something significant; possibly a “Sound the charge!” or a “YOOOO!” reminiscent of a John Wayne movie sound bite or a “Follow me!” of Fort Benning origin. “Move out. Circle the perimeter” with an arm wave was, however, what came out. I recall then LTC Vessey quoted in the news about our arrival saying the event was just like the cavalry charge to the rescue of the wagon train from a John Wayne movie.

The move around the perimeter was eventful. VC at times prone on the ground began running, many toward and some away from us. Some tried to climb onto our tracks as we moved between the firebase and the main VC attack. The 50 caliber machine guns tore into the VC unit but pistols and M-16s kept the VC off the tracks. Sgt Casablanca, my platoon sergeant had been manning one of the turret 50s. His 50 malfunctioned as we arrived and he ended up expending several hundred rounds by hand pumping each individual round into the chamber - an extraordinary physical effort. When the battle ended there were VC bodies every few feet. The total official body count of VC was 647. I understand that this was the single largest enemy body count of the war. Bulldozers were lifted in and the bodies dumped into huge mass graves they created. Thirty-one Americans were killed and 187 wounded.

After it had settled, I took my platoon on a dismounted sweep of the battlefield as helicopters brought in supplies and evacuated our dead and wounded. I was called over to one of the VC bodies by one of my men who believed the VC was still alive. The VC was face down prone on the ground with each hand tucked under his chest. We moved the body by pulling the leg with the use of a pack harness thinking it was booby trapped or that he was still armed. As we did this he began to turn around toward us. A couple of men jumped on him and after a brief struggle, and no unnecessary harm to him, we secured him. I found out later that he was an officer who provided good intelligence.

During the heat of the 3d/22d’s battle, the Air Force and Army artillery had expended a lot of ordnance against the VC attack. The Air Force missions had been directed from a small single-engine prop aircraft by an Air Force fighter pilot serving as a forward air controller (FAC) while another piloted the aircraft. I had known the FAC very well from our time in Ft. Lewis prior to deployment. About a month prior he had swooped down over my position out in the jungle and dropped me a pair of Air Force pilot gloves that I still have. When he was killed he had three more days before he was to leave his FAC responsibilities and go back to flying fighters in-country. Their plane had been shot down during the battle and after things had settled down at the FSB a chopper pilot flying over saw movement at the crash site some distance from the firebase. We believed that the bulk of the withdrawing VC force, the better part of a division, had retreated into or through this area.

LTC Julian ordered my platoon to move rapidly to the location to see if it had been survivors or VC that had been seen at the site. As we approached the crash site we drew fire from our front and flank and then at the site. A platoon from Bravo 2d/22nd was moved into position to reinforce (or save us) if necessary. I ended up not calling them forward and secured the site. We recovered the bodies of both pilots from the wreckage and brought them back. Soon after we had extracted them (given the enemy contact and threat, we all moved very quickly) the aircraft exploded sending me flying about 20 feet. Our movements, I assume, might have put some still hot electrical wires in contact with the gasoline. Of course in-coming fire might have triggered the explosion but we didn’t stick around to investigate.

Well that’s about it. I understand that the battlefield is now under Suoi Tre Lake with the recent damming of a river. Regrettably, I haven’t sat down with another FSB Gold veteran in a very long time. These are old memories now and others can fill in a different perspective or recollection or maybe refresh mine. On that day as on each day of my time in Vietnam I was most privileged to command and serve with the finest men I will ever know. God bless them.

Nine months later on the night of January 1 - 2, 1968 , the Triple Deuce again with the 3d/22 Infantry, and the 2d/77Artillery were involved in a second massive attack by four battalions of NVA and VC at a place called Soui Cut. Soui Cut was just another dot on the map some 8 or 9 klicks northeast of Soui Tre. It was called Fire Support Base Burt in Vietnam. This time Triple Deuce was securing part of the perimeter. When the firing stopped the next morning, over 401 NVA and VC were dead on the battlefield with American losses at 23 killed and 153 wounded. I understand that one of the participants later wrote a screen play and produced the movie "Platoon" loosely presenting the Soui Cut battle as the culminating encounter in the movie.


[1] I certainly do not mean to diminish its contributions and accomplishments right up to the present day. I just don’t know what actions it has engaged in since that date.
[2] In the spirit of full disclosure, I commanded Charlie company for the six months following White. “Chargin Chuck” was an awesome fighting machine. Let me add now that the men, enlisted and non-commissioned infantry, medics, mechanics, drivers and mortars in our whole battalion, in the line companies, Recon and headquarters company were individually and collectively outstanding. Officer leadership varied.
[3] While we had operated as a separate maneuver unit I had direct radio with the battalion commander. Attached to Charlie I had to drop that line to operate on the Charlie Company net - another “insult”.
[4] In subsequent press reports COL Garth, the Brigade CO, was quoted as saying that he had directed that we turn tracks over in the river and cross over them if necessary to breach the river obstacle. Some of the recent accounts suggest that the incident happened, though possibly with some other unit. While I commanded the lead unit I was never given such a directive nor was such a directive, in my memory, ever brought up or discussed in the aftermath of the battle among the participants. During our movement to and entry into Gold, LTC Julian in his bubble top was the only unit commander I saw flying below a 2-3 thousand foot altitude and drawing fire. He flew at tree top level.
[5] One of these LTC’s was the artillery battalion commander at Gold named Vessey. He later in his career became the Chief of Staff of the Army.

For further information try http://www.22ndinfantry.org/vietnam.htm. There are a number of other websites of units who were part of these battles that are worth looking at. As examples: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,941071,00.html http://www.army.mil/cmh/books/Vietnam/90-7/ch13.htm

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The original note was posted on 5/12/07. This is just a brief update to my original note. Recently, I met with LTC Julian (now Col [ret.]) for the first time since 1967 and we spoke about the Soui Tre battle. He informed me that subsequent to my platoon's extraction of the Air Force pilots, another of our units had swept through the area. They found that my platoon, on our way to recover the pilots, had actually driven over and close to a half a dozen buried artillery rounds that had been wired by the VC to command detonate. Apparently the VC had planned their escape route expecting our mechanized unit to chase them and laid the IED's for us. We didn't use the IED term back then although the VC consistently and effectively used "improvised" claymores in the trees and booby traps in the defense of their jungle base camps and buried artillery rounds in the roadways and expected travel routes. The speed of our movement and the effectiveness of our return fire, somehow, kept them from setting off the explosives following Soui Tre.
Grappa, July 31, 2009.

29 comments:

  1. It was a bittersweet experience to read your recollections of the Battle of Soui Tre, Vietnam on March 21, 1967. My childhood friend Pvt. John Oliver Harris fought valiantly and died courageously that day. I have never forgotten him and I appreciate your efforts to keep the memory of those brave, young warriors. Thank You.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Grappa,
    With all the uninvited visitors that dropped by unannounced that morning, we were totally unable to handle the crowd.

    When things started to get ugly and our visitors became unruly and out of control, we tried every form of entertainment we had available. Even though we broke out the behive yard darts game we usually kept hidden in the closet, nothing seemed to work.

    It was so fortunate for us that your team was cruzin' in the area and you were able to drop by and deliver your supply of party favors before they left. That delivery was absolutely "life savering" and immediately helped calm down those unruly rascals. Too bad they didn't stick around longer. You guys in the tracks seemed to be having so much fun, it sure seemed to take some of the tension out of our concerns about not being able to handle the situation and it sure seemed to make their visit a wee-bit enjoyable when they realized that you wanted to play too.

    It was so heart warming to watch your motorized team so efficiently and effectively return some of the warm and personal hospitality as they had providing for our benefit prior to your arrival.

    Although some of the boys went home to their families in boxes, those of us that didn't are forever in your debt, and will never forget.

    Phil C,
    HSB 2/77FA
    AKA Focus-11

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yoh,

    have you considered writing a book re your experiences in Vietnam? Been looking for info re Triple Deuce, thanks for such well written history!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have been visiting various blogs for my term papers writing research. I have found your blog to be quite useful. Keep updating your blog with valuable information... Regards

    ReplyDelete
  5. I shall simply keep silent better

    ReplyDelete
  6. Any one Remember Michael Arlin Balzer,Spc. Silver Star , March 67

    ReplyDelete
  7. Any one Remember Lt Jack Sweeney, Spc Balzer platoon Comamder. Balzer received the Silver Star. I would like to tell his story for the Arlington Cemetery web site.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Phil,

    I was happy to be in the second wave of unannounced visitors. As soon as Roger found the door, it was our pleasure to come in unannounced with the surprise party ending. Our party favors made the day, and even today by many hosts, I am still told our presence was UNEXPECTED, but God sent. Third Brigade Originals have a common bound.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My faather,Sammy Kay, served as a rifle platoon leader at fire base gold with the 2nd 22.He didnt tell many war stories.He told me he did his Duty.

    ReplyDelete
  10. MY name is John R. Cooper. I was at FSB Gold 0n 21 Mar 67 serving as a squad ldr as a member of 1st plt Co. A 3d Bn 22d Inf. and I remember that day pretty well for an old coot. If anyone cares, post notice this website.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This iѕ a tоpіc that iѕ clоѕe to my heart.

    .. Cheers! Whеre are уouг contact ԁetаils though?


    Viѕit my web-sitе: irving cab

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hі, ӏ think уour sitе might bе havіng broωser compаtibility issuеs.
    When I lооk at уоur blog ѕitе in Fіrefοx, it lookѕ fine but whеn oрenіng in Ӏntеrnеt Explorer,
    it has some overlappіng. I just wanted to gіvе you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, terrific blοg!

    Also visit my site: taxi service irving tx

    ReplyDelete
  13. Simply wish to say your article is as astounding.
    The clarity for your post is simply great and that
    i could assume you are knowledgeable on this subject.
    Well along with your permission let me to grasp your feed to keep updated with imminent post.
    Thank you 1,000,000 and please continue the gratifying work.


    Here is my webpage ... landing page template

    ReplyDelete
  14. This post оffers cleaг idea in support of the neω ѵisitoгs of blоgging,
    that genuіnelу hοw to dο running а blog.



    Heге is my webpagе ... seo Company dallas tx

    ReplyDelete
  15. I have been еxploring for а little bit fοr
    аny high quality artісlеs or weblog posts on this kіnd of spacе .
    Explοring in Yahοo I еventuаllу stumbled upon this
    web ѕitе. Reading this info Sо i
    am glad to exрreѕs that I have a vеry gooԁ uncanny fеeling I disсovered exactly ωhat I neeԁed.
    І so much indubitably will make certain to do not overlook this
    web site and proνides it a glancе on a continuing
    basis.

    Review my blog: buy and sell cars for profit

    ReplyDelete
  16. It is approprіate time to mаke some plans for the futurе and it's time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

    My site; allen homes For lease

    ReplyDelete
  17. I almost never comment, but Ι browsed a few rеmarκs here "Recollections of the Battle of Soui Tre, Vietnam on March 21, 1967".
    I аctuаllу dо have 2 questions for
    you if уou don't mind. Is it simply me or do some of these comments look like they are written by brain dead visitors? :-P And, if you are posting at additional online social sites, I'd like to
    folloω eveгything fгesh you
    have to poѕt. Could уou post a list of thе
    сοmplеte urls of all your shаred sites like your Facеbοok pаge, twitter feed,
    oг linkedin pгofіlе?

    Cheсk out my wеb blog ... real estate virtual assistants

    ReplyDelete
  18. luckily, i landed at firebase gold the day AFTER the battle. by then all american dead and wounded had been removed, and the many dead north vietnamese soldiers (approximately 900 of them) had been buried in a huge pit. the carnage of the god-awful battle was everywhere. the men who participated in the fight have all my respect.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I was there and still remember hope nobody has to do that again it was hell I will never forget

    ReplyDelete
  20. Reference to "brain dead comments " can surly strike a cord with those of us who were there on March 20-21.If you were not there, "you do not have a clue"! But, some who have recognized the event by someone else in their lives knows, because they have sat and talked and viewed the pictures. We will only have to defend against the ignorant and those who deny.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I was there. B King. C 2/22
    mtncastle3@aol.com

    ReplyDelete
  22. At daybreak on 21 Mar 67, I departed Tay Ninh on a Visual Recce mission in support of the 196th LIB. I was diverted to Soui Tre at 0640, and became the first FAC at Soui Tre, Issue 44, arriving at 0650. I began coordinating with ground commanders, and with Tiger flight, USAF F-5's from Bien Hoa. Cider 54 arrived with Captain England and Lieutenant Forbes on board. Since Cider FACs were attached to the unit under attack, by policy, I turned the mission over to Cider 54, after leading them across the combat area, and pointing out the enemy concentrations. Cider 54 was shot down after directing Tiger flight. I was redirected to Soui Tre at 0710. I controlled the next flight, B-57's from Clark AB, onto the enemy AAW site to allow FAC and fighter aircraft to fly close air support of the ground forces. By 0720 the AAW was silenced. I then directed the B-57's to drop 4x750 pound bombs and 8x750 pound napalms on enemy concentrations to the northeast. I turned the mission over to a Cider FAC at approximately 0740, and assisted in locating the downed FAC aircraft, Cider 54. At roughly 0800 I assisted 2 Army helicopters in locating the downed aircraft. Tragically, both FACs were KIA.

    Is there a central comm location for Battle of Soui Tre veterans? You indicated you knew one of the USAF FACs.

    Bob Staib, Plano TX (Captain, USAF) bobstaib@mac.com

    ReplyDelete
  23. My father, Herman "Chip" Gaede, was at Firebase Gold as part of Battery B, 2d/77th. I knew he had seen a lot during his time in Vietnam, but I had no idea until recently, just how incredible the story of the battle at Suoi Tre was.

    Thank you to all who were there.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I lost my brother in that battle Sp4 James D Brewer A. Co. 3/22. He Was transferred from b.CO. 3/21 196TH LIB on march 18th. He was manning the quad 50 at the time it was hit by a RPG.
    RIP peace to all who gave there lives.
    snoopy4545769@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  25. Balzer, Michael A Spe4
    CoA 3rdBn. 22d Inf. 3 Bde. 4th Inf. Div.
    KIA 21Mar1967
    Silver Star, Purple Heart, Presidential Unit Citation

    ReplyDelete
  26. When to Write? If you do not believe, or were not there, you are not entitled to an opinion. Ask those who were there or come to the next Soui Tre Reunion and listen. Those who learn the most often say the least and are then humbled by what they walk away with. You may forget, but those were at "Gold", or "Burt", or "Trapizoid", and unnamed spots will never forget. Veterans of Combat cannot forget.

    George

    ReplyDelete
  27. I lost my dear friend in the Battle of Suoitre - Operation Junction City. His name was Thomas Utter from Hinsdale, Ill. He was 2nd platoon leader, Company C 2nd Battalion 22nd Infantry. Is there anyone out there who knew this wonderful man??? Please email me at hdixon@wi.rr.com.

    ReplyDelete
  28. 50th anniversary & Honor Ceremony being held March 21, 2017 in Colorado Springs, Co Info available on www.originalboatpeople.com
    Or call Bill King (C2/22) 719-748-8219 home or 719-494-3590 my reunion e mail is billkingsouitre@aol.com
    Hope you can attend, tel others who were there.
    Bless all

    ReplyDelete
  29. WE are all old timers now. Many are already at rest. Col Garth (LTG Garth) died in Phoenix several years ago. LTC Vessey (GEN Vessey) passed last year.. CPT Shugart (COL Shugart) I believe lives in Midlothian, VA. Bless all of those at rest and all of us who remain.

    ReplyDelete